Is A/D-converter research in Europe about to die?


Number of scientific publications reporting measured A/D-converter implementations –by first-author affiliation location.

Is A/D-converter research in Europe about to die … or has it just gone into hiding? Well, looking at the publication statistics for measured ADC implementations justifies the question. In the overall publication count, there aren’t any signs of concern – Europe still has an accumulated 27% after North America’s 50% and before Asia’s 23% of all publications, as shown in a previous post. But Europe has lost a significant amount of wind in the last five years, which is obvious from the year-by-year stats shown in the plot. It seems that North America is maintaining its leadership in publications, but that Asia picked up some serious speed by 2006, while research publications from affiliations in Europe simultaneously dropped dramatically. North America and Asia both shows a steady increase, and note also that Asia has a steeper slope than North America. Europe is the only region that appears to level out at a lower publication rate. Why?

  • Is Europe lacking the financial or intellectual muscle required to compete with North America and Asia?
  • Is it a European view that the A/D-converter is a “commodity” that is best supplied from elsewhere and nothing of interest remains to be researched?
  • Did European research “go into hiding” within companies and institutions that put a lid on their research results for commercial reasons? In that case, is the lack of publications merely a sign of good “industrial health”?
  • Or has Europe simply lost its vision for ADC research?

What do you think? Share your thoughts and insights by leaving a comment or by taking the poll (multiple choices allowed).

.

A few comments and remarks:

  • The underlying data set is the same as in [1], but data for 2010 have been excluded since the results for 2010 are not settled yet. The main sources surveyed are listed here.
  • Data and graphics is from a large ADC technology and research survey, and is courtesy of ADMS Design AB. (See also the ADMS Design pressroom for other results from the survey)
  • Since I know a lot of people in Sweden and Europe that are active in ADC research, these results were surprising to me. My impression is (still) that there’s a lot going on in Europe, and therefore I would have expected all regions of the world to be increasing their publication rate.
  • Obviously there are a lot of things to be said about how well a simple measure like “paper count” detects the research activity of a region. Nevertheless, there is a clearly different trend for Europe, and it does raise some interesting questions about what’s going on.

See also …

ADC Survey Data

References

[1] B. E. Jonsson, “A survey of A/D-converter performance evolution”, accepted for presentation, IEEE Int. Conf. Electronics Circ. Syst. (ICECS), Athens, Greece, Dec., 2010.

Advertisements

6 responses to “Is A/D-converter research in Europe about to die?

  1. Thanks Bengt! Very interesting.

    What about the relative statistics? Can anything be said about the grand total number of published papers by Europeans? Is the field of data converters shrinking or is it a general trend that the number of publications in IC design is decreased in Europe?

  2. @Jacob:
    Good idea! That’s an interesting question that would certainly add to the overall picture. Unfortunately, I don’t have the statistics to answer it yet, since I only surveyed ADCs (and more than a fair bit of DACs, but I’m not finished with them just yet).

    If we get completely snowed-in here (first snow predicted for Wednesday), and no one else delivers the overall IC stats before me, I might take a look at it.

  3. And thanks a lot for the kind words on your mixed-signal blog.

    http://mixedsignal.wordpress.com

  4. Pingback: Back from NORCHIP | Converter Passion

  5. Pingback: ICECS 2010 at a glance | Converter Passion

  6. Pingback: Reader question: Why is the data converter market dominated by six US companies? | Converter Passion

Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s